I personally will not be voting for anything that uses these tools, in the same way that I won’t be voting for anything that was built with a lot of corporate funding or which was built by a big team (games which are, also, probably pretty good!). I simply won’t forfeit this rare moment of agency unimpeded by work or rent or other obligations, and just say “yeah, well, that’s the way it is.”
Austin Walker lays out the arguments against Big Walk for the IGFs in a very clear-minded way. I really appreciate how he breaks down both the problem of the moment (whether or not to consider BW for IGFs) and the larger issue (the connection between AI Tech and broader systems of global harm).
These hypotheticals are used as the fuel for a fatalistic position in which AI is inevitable. (I say this because even the AI boosters are increasingly fatalists of a sort, as they realize that it might be a method to perform regulatory capture). This position closes off the possibility that these tools are something we can choose not to use, leveraging an imagined future-history as a cudgel to imagination itself (and in the case of employment being tied to it, as an outright threat).
